Review – Return to Moria

Won't You Take Me to Goblin Town!


Developer Free Range Games
Publisher North Beach Games
Genre Survival
Platforms PC (reviewed)
Release Date Oct. 24, 2023

Return to Moria is the highly anticipated video game that plunges players into the heart of Middle-earth, offering an immersive experience within the enchanting lore of J.R.R. Tolkien’s The Lord of the Rings. Developed by Tolkien Interactive Studios, this game promises to be a thrilling adventure, combining captivating gameplay with an authentic connection to the beloved source material. In this comprehensive review, we will delve into the gameplay mechanics, the seamless integration of Middle-earth’s lore, and the overall experience that Return to Moria delivers to players.


Players use swords, axes, hammers, bows and arrows, and melee-style attacks to kill enemies. Battles are highlighted by impact sounds, cries of pain, and small blood-splatter effects.

During the course of the game, players’ character can brew and consume various types of alcohol (e.g., ale, lager, stout).


Return to Moria’s gameplay serves as the backbone of this Middle-Earth adventure. It successfully combines exploration, combat, and puzzle-solving to deliver a captivating and authentic experience. Players step into the shoes of a newly-created character, a dwarven adventurer, who embarks on a quest to explore the ancient dwarven city of Khazad-dûm, commonly known as Moria. Exploration is at the core of the game, allowing players to traverse the labyrinthine tunnels, grand chambers, and shadowy depths of Moria. The level design is exceptional, capturing the awe-inspiring grandeur of the city’s architecture and the perilous beauty of its subterranean landscapes. The sense of scale and detail is breathtaking, as players navigate the treacherous pathways and delve deeper into the mysteries of this iconic location.

The game’s open-world design is a particular highlight, encouraging players to discover hidden secrets and engage in side quests that are woven into the larger narrative. The feeling of embarking on a grand adventure, with new discoveries around every corner, is a testament to the game’s meticulous design.

Return to Moria features an intricate combat system that immerses players in the thrill of battle. The game’s diverse enemy roster, which includes goblins, orcs, cave trolls, and other menacing creatures, provides a formidable challenge. Players must adapt their combat strategies to overcome different foes, keeping the experience engaging and dynamic.

Moria is renowned for its complex architecture and intricate mechanisms, and the game embraces this aspect by integrating clever puzzles and riddles into the player’s journey. These challenges are deeply rooted in Middle-earth’s lore, drawing inspiration from Tolkien’s writings. Solving these puzzles provides a sense of intellectual achievement and a connection to the lore, which is sure to satisfy die-hard Tolkien fans.

The storytelling in Return to Moria is good. It immerses players in the lore, recounting the city’s history and the events leading up to its fall. The game also introduces a gripping original storyline that maintains the spirit of Tolkien’s universe while adding fresh layers of intrigue and excitement. I won’t touch on much else to keep players’ minds fresh when they go in.

Return to Moria shines in terms of both art and sound design. The visuals capture the essence of Middle-Earth’s stunning landscapes, richly detailed characters, and atmospheric lighting. The sound design features a pleasant musical score, composed in a style reminiscent of Howard Shore’s work for the film adaptations. The echoing halls of Moria, the ominous growls of goblins, and their whispers all contribute to an immersive experience.

The vastness of Moria and the multitude of quests, collectibles, and side activities make Return to Moria a game that earns players to return again and again. The multiple character classes and the freedom to explore different playstyles also enhance replayability. Completing every quest, uncovering all secrets, will take a considerable amount of time, making this game a rewarding investment for fans of Middle-Earth.

The game’s performance is smooth, even on less powerful hardware, and the attention to detail in character animations and environmental effects is commendable. The developers have also ensured regular updates to fix any potential bugs and improve the overall player experience.

Return to Moria is here to stay in the world of video game adaptations, as opposed to Gollum. Its gameplay, connection to the lore of Middle-earth, and dedication to the source material will entertain both fans of The Lord of the Rings and gamers seeking a captivating adventure. The game’s unique storytelling and mechanics combine to deliver an experience that will keep players enthralled for quite a while. In the words of Gandalf himself, “All we have to decide is what to do with the time that is given us,” and spending it in Moria is a decent undertaking.

The Bottom Line


Return to Moria doesn't challenge the genre, and instead of just tries to be a good game, and in that it suceeds.



Posted in , ,

Johnathan Floyd

Writer, Editor, President, and overall complete goofball.

Leave a Comment